Repair or Replace: The Biggest Question in North Dallas HVAC

• The age of the unit and the overall cost of the repair are the two biggest items driving this decision
• Upgrading your unit leads to lower energy bills, more consistent comfort, and warranty protection
• Always get a second quote to ensure fair pricing
• Colony offers free second opinions on all replacements

Call 972.591.0293 See Other Articles

It’s a Case of Sticker Shock

When your air conditioner or furnace breaks down, your only focus is on getting it running again. So, you call a local HVAC company out to your home in Frisco or Plano. After carefully diagnosing the problem and determining the required repair, they deliver a quote of $1500.

That’s not what you were expecting. You thought it would be a few hundred bucks, but it turns out a major repair is needed, requiring both an expensive part and a lot of labor hours. Suddenly, you’re debating whether paying for the repair is smart or if you should just get a quote on a new system.

Countless homeowners have faced this situation in North Dallas, and we’d like to provide some perspective. We offer free second opinions on quotes over $500. Use the information below as a guideline and call us at 972.591.0293 if you’d like input from an experienced, helpful HVAC professional.

The Factors Impacting this Decision

Let’s look at a few of the key points you’ll want to think about when deciding whether to repair or replace HVAC equipment. None of these points alone will decide for you, but weighing them together will help the picture come into focus.

• Unit Age: This is the best starting point in deciding what to do. If your HVAC equipment is already past its tenth birthday, you should think more carefully about replacement. Paying to repair an old AC unit or heat pump may leave you looking at another costly repair in the near future.
• Parts Availability: Is it getting harder and harder for your HVAC technician to find the right parts to fix your air conditioner or furnace? When parts become scarce, repairs get more expensive, and replacement starts to look more appealing.
• Repair Cost: For repairs under $300, you probably won’t think too hard about replacing the whole system. However, if the repair is over $1,000 on an older system or over $2,500 on any system, you should at least consider upgrading.
• Length of Stay in Home: Are you planning on moving out in the near future? If so, paying only for the repair to get the system working again would make sense, leaving replacement to the new owner. With that said, if you’ll be living in your house for years to come, upgrading is a decision that will benefit your family.

A Quick Breakdown

The Many Benefits of Upgrading to a New Unit

If you think that replacing your old HVAC equipment is just spending a lot of money to get the same performance, think again. Depending on your current system’s age, you could enjoy a dramatically upgraded experience by installing new HVAC equipment in Carrollton or Frisco.

• Improved Efficiency: Modern HVAC equipment is more efficient than older systems. That means you’ll use less energy than before to get the same performance. That means monthly utility savings and a lower environmental impact, too.
• Consistent Comfort: Have you noticed that your current HVAC system isn’t maintaining an even temperature throughout the house? That’s a common issue with older air conditioners, and it can be frustrating when summer temperatures soar in Frisco. It’s also a potential symptom that your unit is undersized. With a new system, your whole house will be nice and comfortable all year long.
• Warranty Protection: There is also the peace of mind that comes with a new system. Almost all new HVAC equipment you purchase will come with a manufacturer’s warranty of between five and ten years. So, by investing in a new air conditioner or furnace, you can then set aside repair worries (as long as you keep your system maintained).

Start by Getting a Repair Quote

This whole process starts with getting a repair quote. Only with a firm, honest quote in hand can you make an informed choice about what should come next.

You don’t want to rush into replacing your system before you know what you are actually facing. What if the repair is only going to be a couple hundred dollars? Or is it just a case of someone forgetting to change the filter?

In that case, you’ll probably just pay to have it fixed, and you can hold off on replacement until a later date.

What If Another Company Already Told You to Replace the Unit?

If another HVAC contractor in North Dallas has told you that a new unit will be required, we suggest looking more closely at that recommendation.

You should have a specific, legitimate reason for replacing the air conditioner or furnace. For example, if an inspection revealed a failed compressor on an old AC unit, that’s a good reason. Or, if your old heat pump uses R-22 refrigerant and is leaking, that’s another strong case for replacement. However, if you were told that replacement is necessary and the technician didn’t even inspect your system, you should be suspicious.

Any vague explanation or time pressure that suggests you need to decide immediately should also give you pause.

At Colony, we are happy to take another look at your system if you would like us to confirm what the other company has told you. These second opinions are complimentary. We’ll also never pressure you into something you don’t need.

When AC Repair Makes Sense

Repair will often be the right call for HVAC issues. Not in every case, of course, but there are plenty of times when a repair provided by an experienced HVAC technician will set you up for many years of reliable performance without the expense of a system replacement. Here are some signs that point to repair being the logical choice:

• The system is less than 10 years old. If you’ve only had the air conditioner or furnace for a few years, the equipment probably has a lot left to give. Most of the repairs that are common at this stage, like capacitors, contactors, and sensors, are pretty affordable.
• The system is well-maintained. Have you been doing a good job of keeping up with annual maintenance and changing the air filter? If you are up on those tasks, your system should be in good condition overall, and there is every reason to believe that the repair will be the only work needed.
• An isolated failure. Talk with your technician about the type of failure that has caused your air conditioner or furnace to stop working. If it’s something isolated, like a capacitor or flame sensor, that issue is unlikely to become a systemic problem.

When It’s Time to Get a New AC

Going the other direction from the previous section, there are occasions when choosing to replace your HVAC equipment is the easy and obvious option.

• The system is more than 15 years old. It’s going to be hard to justify any significant repair on an air conditioner or furnace that has been serving your home for more than 15 years. A unit at that stage of life probably doesn’t have much more to give, so repairing it won’t delay the inevitable.
• The repair is 50% of the replacement cost. If your repair bill is going to be around 50% or more of what it would cost to replace the whole system, stop and think twice. Going with the new unit and its warranty will be the better financial decision in the long run.
• The system uses R-22 refrigerant. Since R-22 production has ended, remaining supplies are becoming scarce and have gotten quite expensive. If the repair you are facing involves a refrigerant leak, it’ll get costly. This is probably the time to upgrade to a unit with a modern refrigerant.
• There is a pattern of repairs. Are you noticing that the time between HVAC repairs is getting shorter and shorter? If you are calling often for AC or furnace repairs in Frisco, that’s a good sign of system-wide failure and the need for a new unit.

Two Easy Ways to Make Your Equipment Last Longer

Stepping away from the repair-vs-replacement debate for a moment, is there anything you can do to make sure your equipment lasts as long as possible? Absolutely. In fact, there are two key steps you can take to get the most out of any piece of HVAC equipment in North Dallas.

Why Hiring the Right Company for AC Replacement is Crucial

An HVAC replacement project is too important to trust to just anyone. You need an experienced, proven partner like Colony Air Conditioning & Heating to make sure everything goes right. Here are some of the key points that you’ll be able to hit by hiring the right company.

• Proper system sizing. Only an experienced team of technicians can do the calculations needed to ensure the new HVAC unit is the right size. Don’t assume you simply need the same-sized unit as the one that’s already there.
• Licensing and insurance. Electrical work, gas line connections, and refrigerant handling are involved in most HVAC installation projects. There are licenses and certifications required for such jobs, and every company should carry insurance to protect you in case something goes wrong. Ask for proof, and if a contractor won’t provide it, move on to the next one.
• Permit handling. A legitimate HVAC contractor will pull permits for you. If you don’t have a permit in place, you might have trouble when you go to sell your home, and the warranty that comes with your new air conditioner or furnace may be voided.

Call Colony Air Conditioning & Heating to Figure Out if Repair or Replacement is the Way to Go

You don’t have to make this important decision in Frisco or Plano alone. At Colony, we offer honest, straightforward advice to customers facing this dilemma. We don’t believe in aggressive sales tactics and will never push you into a decision that isn’t in your best interest. Instead, we’ll have an open and honest conversation about whether HVAC repair or replacement makes the most sense given the situation at hand.

Whether you live by Little Elm Park or closer to the Sea Life Grapevine Aquarium, we’ll be happy to visit your location and give our expert opinion.

Frequently Asked Questions